Showing posts with label Yashraj. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yashraj. Show all posts

Sunday, May 31, 2009

Truth of Reality Shows

Real TV & its reality showsI have always been against reality shows – be it song and dance shows where all and sundry come as judges and give expert opinion on points where they never were experts themselves or be it the other shows that come with public voting - where region, religion, caste, colour and looks play a more active role than excellence. Here, I must make it clear that only comedy shows make good reality shows in my view. Whatever is left… is completed by the channel in the name of TRPs. They never have to disclose the actual sms messages. Shinjini case only proved my point that these could be harmful to the contestants’ confidence if not handled properly. It would come so early, was not expected by me.
I always advocated that these could be good, if used constructively and that show also came earlier than I had expected – SITARON KO CHOONA HAI. In my view, it is one of the constructive way to use reality TV (talking of programmes that need the contestants to show daily progress in the format).
Recently, a new television channel Real TV started in March. Two reality shows started almost simultaneously – SARKAAR KI DUNIYA is the other one. I will compare both the shows and let the readers decide which is better. I will write about the progress of both one by one.

SARKAAR KI DUNIYA
This programme started with 18 contestants. Every week they are assigned a task and they earn GINNIS to remain in the game. The game has just crossed three quarter mark and has seen all the bad phases that a show with unruly contestants can. You name a cuss word and it has been spoken here. You name a trick and it has already been played. Stealing of Ginnis (not once but thrice), emotional blackmail for acquisition of Ginnis, groupism, using words to make other group emotionally unstable, stealing of taxes and using innovative ways for earning & denying Ginnis to the opposite group. It looks like every minute they spend in the show, somebody is planning downfall of someone from the other group. They seem to be behaving like a bunch of scorpions, who instead of climbing to the top, never let the other ones from climbing and in the process all remain in the deep pit of jealousy, distrust and deceit. I agree, being greedy, we humans behave more aggressively when there is money involved but my point is why at all give them the chance. Try some healthy and constructive shows like the one I am comparing this show with. Here, I also want to give the + and – points of every contestant (behavior), name wise. I am doing this because I want the money to go into the lap of the best of the remaining contestants. Specially, my targets are Ali and Sumisha (who don’t deserve the money at all). Here it follows:

1. Muskan Arun Bhonsle: Eliminated – Bar Dancer. Being the first one to get voted out, nothing can be said about her personality; then she left because of her father’s failing health so her bad mood could also be responsible for her niggle or two. Want to mention one more thing out of context here that India is not a great place to live in for eunuchs. Why can’t they get equal opportunities and normal life like others? Why do they have to face hardships and separation from biological families? Muskan was a bar dancer and in Northern India they forcefully extract money from the couples getting married or giving birth to new ones. I don’t know much about their condition elsewhere. I wish 15th Lok Sabha gets to answer these questions and its members get to live their plight.
2. Shikha Arya Puri: Eliminated – Marriage Planner. Strong Lady; could take the fight to the opposition. She lost the fight because maybe she was a strong contender. She could be a good leader also. Again went too early to know what she would have done in tense situations.
3. Riya Ray: Eliminated – Model/ Actress. Nice person; realized early on that this game was too harsh for her and got herself voted out by literally requesting. This is more truthful compared to Qazi’s stand that neither will I work not leave.
4. Sanjiv Gupta: Eliminated – re-nominated in the game – Page 3 journalist. Another lazy contender besides Qazi Tauqeer. Give him any task and he’ll show how not to do it properly. As his job demands, he gets involved in gossips much more than normal. Wants respect but does not believe in earning it. May have given birth to a few fights in the team or among fellow contestants. Still among the better humans of the lot. Has returned again. Still to be seen how he behaves in tense situations. He was the first contestant to run out of favour of the fellow contestants. He deserves better behavior after the treatment he received from fellow contestants and being one of the better humans deserves to win the money along with Rashid Ali but I think he will again get trapped. If he doesn’t get tricked and manages to go till top five, I would prefer Sanjiv Vs. Rashid and to some extent Puneesh for the prize money of Rs. One Crore.
5. Nandini Lall: Eliminated – Farmer. Nice human, believed too much in her group. Got emotionally blackmailed by Ali, who is responsible for many a controversies. Worked for the team and being a farmer took good care of the animals also. When Ali stole Ginnis of Jagdish, she too became a party later on, when she came to know but never opened his histrionics so, wasn’t that innocent either. Still deserved more weeks in the game then she spent.
6. Shamaun Ali: Eliminated – Disk Jockey. Again better humans of the lot. He too became a victim of Ali’s emotional blackmail. Was again a party to Ali’s theft as he too didn’t disclose the fact. Deserved more time.
7. Jatinder Pal Singh: Eliminated – Corporate executive. Played the game as corporate executive only. Totally emotionless game. Was a close confidant of Jagdish Italia in all his calculations to rise to the final five. Being a corp. exec., was very comfortable with groupism. How and what good his prayers were, I fail to understand. Prayers and belief in God make a person a better human being and teaches kindness not ruthlessness.
8. Koneenika Banerjee: Eliminated – Actress. Rebel. Emotional. Sensitive. Faithful (to the extent of doing wrong to the others for near ones). Low self-esteem. Always seen fighting Ali and others for her rights. Duties, she wanted to perform but only after she got her rights fulfilled. Was the most used-misused person in the game and again Ali Mughal was responsible for it. Overstayed her time. Her unstable behavior was a bad influence for the audience. Still could be pardoned as she was fighting for life on two fronts – her group leader and the rest of the gang.
9. Shehan Nawal Dutta: Eliminated – Martial Arts Trainer. Really deserved to stay till the last week as he was not involved in groupism till his final days. Did only one mistake early on that he didn’t prize good job with extra ginnis and kept all the extra ginnis. Got penalized for it a bit too much. Had he believed in his cause (of providing an Olympian to India in martial arts), maybe God would have helped him but he became more ambitious (my belief). Still, deserved to stay more. Became a victim of strategic planning by the groups in the game.
10. Neeru Goswami: Eliminated – Actress. Rustic. Still, better ones among the fellow contestants. Lived her course of life. Became part of groupism. Fell a victim of groupism.
11. Qazi Tauqeer: Eliminated – Actor/ Singer. Mr Lazy bones rather a sloth. He is so lazy that he takes the bath weekly … oooowww. Still he has the guile to say that he is great (not his fault… he too is a narcisst). Didn’t even deserve a place in the game as he was always working to find the way out to get away. One of the nicer of the lot otherwise but still was involved in many a gossips. Not an ideal for the viewers of impressionable age. Was treated to very harsh behavior sometimes but still he preferred to stay away from work. Harshest comment came from the King of controversies Ali Mughal again, when he told him that even a beggar sitting on the crossings sings better. It hurts. Even Sumisha, who knew she is surviving on his ginnis, didn’t show mercy. Such hypocrisy. Well, who said, this game was for nice people. More than half the contestants left are crooks and this is an understatement.
12. Sumisha Shankar: Got voted out once – Ex-Captain Indian Army. Served the army maybe on a short service commission officer. If Ali is the king, she wins the crown of Queen of controversies very comfortably. Great planner. She has executed three. Two tasks (first one shoddy road construction just to save the ginnis and second one being the boat house) and third one stealing Qazi’s ginnis from Puneesh’s bag. Asked for ginnis from almost everyone who left early and she was comfortable talking to. Her ginnis got stolen to bring her to use nefarious ways but maybe that too is her strategy (you can’t say it with authority when she is involved). Wants recognition with gains. Among the first ones to revolt during Jagdish’s reign. Wanted to show moral ground but she needs to learn morals again from the scratch. Knowing that she didn’t have her weight in Jagdish’s group she was the first one to tie up clandestinely with rival group. For her motive she can go to any length. Well, this is a game but how far you can go is a limit one has to set. When she was weak, she even separated her kitchen alongwith Shweta (her partner in every crime/ strategy). Doesn’t deserve a single day in the game though, I admire her never say die spirit.
13. Shweta Rawat: Eliminated - A voice-over artiste. Puppet of Sumisha. Shifted loyalty towards Ali in his last week. Moralistic pangs never hit her. Involved in the theft of ginnis of Qazi and then she could take the plate from his hands because he was lazy (yet another copycat act following Sumisha’s, just a day before). Her only independent move was to re-build bridges with Ali Moghul. Ironically, he and Sanjiv Gupta were the first ones out of her favour (whom she said, she couldn’t tolerate a day in the game). According to her Sanjiv Gupta was a lecher and Ali a rotten person who didn’t know how to respect women and who didn’t know the limits when dealing with girls. One can either feel bad or not at all but she felt bad when she knew she could get away with it and when Ali had most of the ginnis, she patched up with him and that too in a way that cannot be discussed. A pest (needs someone to latch on to-to survive). Where did her stand go when faced with adversity, I will never find out. As far as this behavior is concerned, I think this is what would have led to the start of oldest profession in the world. Disgusting, but this is what the level of our society is. Selfish, mean and cunning. Conscience, what is it. Today’s generation can do anything for money. Still …. has over lived her time. Didn’t deserve to continue. She confessed in her final message that stealing Qazi's ginnis was again the idea of king of bad actions Ali Wasim Raja Mughal.
14. Rashid Ali: Trader. Strong contender for the final stage. One of the richest in the game. Now my candidate to win the money after Shehan’s exit. He is involved in groupism and has been part of a bit of dramatics and all but still he is the one who has got some of the conscience left (but only a little bit of it) if we exclude Sanjiv Gupta, who was out of the game for most of the game. Yes, only problem is that I don’t know whether he will be able to put the money for his and society’s best use or not. This is the point where Puneesh and Sanjiv Gupta score over him.
15. Puneesh Sharma: Civil Engineer/ Contractor. Again a strong contender for final. Can do anything to win the game (don’t know, if he could steal or not as he has never faced that desperate situation). He has broken and re-formed a splinter group a la Sumisha. Played moves that suited him. Some of his moves have really changed the game upside down and without much histrionics involved. He is indeed a schemer and an intelligent person. Can’t be trusted but among the few left and almost assured of the final five berths. He barely manages to be among the top three, I would settle for to vote for a win. I know, he is a schemer and bad too but among the remaining ones, he seems to know how to better utilise one’s resources and that will benefit the society at large. In fact, as far as my recognition power goes in these terms, he is the best (counting on my financial consultancy experience of about two decades). Besides, he has good leadership qualities too that Rashid and Sanjiv lack.
16. Jagdish Italia: Trader/ Runs a School as NGO. Is a master strategist. Always planning the downfall of someone or the other. Negative attitude. Yes, he is a narcissist too(read inscriptions on his Tees). One of the first ones to understand the game and creating outcasts among fellow contestants. Nice guys finish last. So, why take the risk but for public perception, one can seem nice and hide behind smartly phrased sentences. Conscience – only good to teach the kids. Who needs them anyway, if he wins the game? Still keep him away from the booty as he was the one to take the initiative of groupism after Ali had ganged up with some.
17. Vishwas Sangwan: Student. Shweta of Jagdish. Will do whatever Jagdish tells him to. A quiet spoke in the heart. Keeps his cards closer to heart. Speaks less maybe because doesn’t want to speak whatever is on his mind. Since he is devoid of any ideology and action and other qualities that make a person eligible for the win, he doesn’t deserve the money but on the other hand it is better not to do anything bad than be a bad person, so, I would have taken him to the last five, had the game been in my hands (that is the most he deserves). Surprise... Surprise, he too was involved in the stealing of ginnis (Qazi's) according to the confession of Shweta. So, he isn't worth the respect either.

18. Wasim Ali Raza Mughal: Fitness trainer. And lastly, on to the person who deserves to be in the game – the least (should have been unsuccessful and out of the game by now as he is really negative in his approach towards life). Worst kind of influence. Will play any trick in the trade to get whatever his motive is and to stay on focus i.e. get the footage. Has played most of emotional blackmails. Involved in at least two thefts, once when he was desperate and another when he was in a strong position (his target was puneesh’s ginni bag but Sumisha ended up with Qazi’s - Shweta confessed it in her final message that idea of stealing Qazi's ginnis was indeed his). Is quarrelsome. In fact, has had a tiff with everyone except Nandini and Shamaun Ali. Far ahead of every other contestant in any sort of dirty trick that has been played here. Was even seen plotting against Koneenika Banerjee in her last week and only after some calculations (which I don’t remember now) showed that he will lose power with her exit that he reverted his stand (and he voted out Shehan Nawal with this very reason). Very low self-esteem and therefore will make destructive use of his money. Tries to pin down the opponent by hook or crook. Doesn’t hesitate in using matters of faith even. Started using Jetty as Worship place as it had the camera and he had stolen Jagdish's Ginnis that very week. He wanted to project his good worshipping image to the public. Once, I gave a loan to a Muslim person for treatment on the guarantee of a friend (I happened to know that person only through this friend). He didn’t return the money. About two years later, he was telling about that person to his cousin that “You can’t trust these Muslims, he (blah-blah)”. I only asked him one thing, “I may have given the money to that person but actually whom did I trust, who broke my trust?” In my view, that friend was using faith to hide his guilt of not repaying me. Ali is that sort of person, who will accuse anyone of anything to save his skin. He wants to use any measure but can't tolerate if the others person even uses counter-attack measures. I don’t want to write much on this disgusting person. He is into final five. I would urge the readers of this blog and viewers of the programme not to vote for his gain. He will ultimately use the money to ruin the peace of some person. DO NOT LET THIS PERSON GET AWAY WITH MONEY WHICH WILL BECOME A WEAPON OF MASS DESTRUCTION IN HIS HANDS. [ONE MORE THING I WANT TO POINT THE ATTENTION TO. QAZI FOUND FORTY OF HIS STOLEN 123 GINNIS AND ALI WAS SEEN SEARCHING FOR THE GINNIS IN THE DEBRIS AND THOSE GINNIS WERE ALSO FORTY AND IN HIS WORDS, HIDDEN 2-3 WEEKS AGO – SAME TIME AS QAZI LOST HIS GINNIS. MEANS, QAZI’S GINNIS GOT SPLIT BETWEEN SUMISHA, SHWETA AND ALI SORRY, WASIM RAJA MUGHAL – NO TRUE FRIENDSHIPS IN THE GAME …. RIGHT?

SITARON KO CHOONA HAIBefore this show, I only wished that there should be such a show. I had a concept in mind. This show has many a similarities with my own concept. This show is constructive and actually hones the professional skills of the contestants. Compared to SKD, this show has had just one major controversy in the entire show (Yashraj and Kashishh love angle). Yes, there is a bit of complex (superiority and inferiority) problem between the fellow contestants and a bit of ego tussle is also there. Still, mostly there is harmony and those who have left have also improved during their stay. I was so impressed with the show that I wanted to write a book on this show, faculty and its contestants. The faculty Prashant A. Samadhar (vocal trainer), Neha Bhasin (Overall performance mentor), Pritpal, Akhil and Rishiraj have teamed up with faculty head Raghu Ram (of Roadies fame) to guide and train 12 youngsters to improve upon their skills and become performers in their career as singers. Being artistes also these people seem to be nice than the people mentioned above. Anyway, I will write about them in brief here:

1. Ankita Bhattacharjee: Sent Back – First one to leave the faculty. A young and sweet girl. Would have proved a good bet for on screen roles also. Was unsuccessful in her pursuit. I think she and Pankaj Sharma got the harsh treatment to set an example for the others to become serious if they want to stay in the faculty.
2. Pankaj Sharma: Sent Back – He too lost favour of the faculty quite early. He was a nice person too. In fact, all the contestants here are better humans than the ones in SKD. Being young, he was not that much serious and paid the price for his attitude.
3. Laxmi Nagar: Sent Back – The person who could never find anything right as she was also quite low on confidence. She felt that was her way to get the attention of faculty and the public at large. Otherwise, she was a nice person. Will rue the chances she got again and again.
4. Kashishh: Sent Back – Was involved in a controversy that never should have arisen here. She was here not for that. Even the way she behaved was not the right thing to do as it would not have changed the situation but anyway she did that in the fit of rage. Otherwise, she was most diligent in her practice. She simply could not compete with the talent of the rest of eight. I think, she has had her bed of thorns (in personal life) and needs to change her career if she feels that she is lagging behind and may fail to make her prospects better. She is young and may adjust in another career which becomes difficult with every passing year.
5. Sreeju Premarajan: Sent Back – Was the first one to go amongst the equals. Performed good in patches. A jovial guy and never too serious. That is what cost him his chance to move forward. Had a good style quotient too. Will definitely succeed because he has a good performance brain but will need to shed his attitude a bit to achieve that feat.
6. Wajahat-Ul-Hasan: Sent Back – Was definitely quite trained as it seemed from a distance to me even (I am an enthusiast but not trained for music). He was given the maximum number of chances because he lacked a basic attitude towards audience. Stage fright took its toll on him and he seemed to have lost it in the mind before coming on the performance arena. Will take a long time as stage fear has taken many a careers.
7. Veena Parashar: Sent Back – My favourite, as like Sreeju she too is full of life. I prefer to take things on hand seriously but life – never. She tried hard but yes never too hard that it becomes overbearing. On one hand that makes you better in life but you tend to bloom late in life and like I said of Sreeju, she too will emerge a winner later in life.
8. Shantanu Sudame: I truly like his daring attitude and honesty. His thoughts are clear. Doesn’t want much from anybody just his own life. Maybe, his life early on has taught him to bank on his abilities only. This type of person is most capable of trying to put life back on track after a failure. This type of person therefore, ends up succeeding in life though it may take long or worst case scenario, if they don’t succeed they don’t completely fail either. His cuss words though hurt me more than anyone on the SKD using swear words, these words don’t suit artists.
9. Anu Arora: A hard worker. Her forte in my view lies in folk. She also has a kind heart and takes the risks that Veena or even Neelakshi shy away from taking (I think that is what cost Veena a place in the final stages). She has a fine heart too (was the first one to forgive Yash after his false statements to Faculty in the only controversy of the programme). Deserves more than she has achieved till now. Maybe, faculty expects much more from her as she can perform quite a a lot more than the mettle she has shown here. She has got a really melodious voice.
10. Neelakshi Bhattacharya: A sweet and soft spoken personality. She is a true Bengali I would say and has therefore a real sweet voice. That is her most positive asset. Among more hard workers and that is why has reached here. This young lass has a lot of training behind her and deserves to win in life. She has her whole life ahead and will definitely win.
11. Padmanav Bordoloi: The final fight should be between him and Yash. If Yash has vocal control better than him, he too has mastered the art of communicating with the audience that no one else in contention could. Though Sreeju and Veena also were witty behind the stage but his wits show on screen and the audience loves it.
12. Yashraj Kapil: The other part of controversy and he was responsible for it. Never wanted to own up till it was on his throat. Not honest but has done most practice in life (I think) but the fact is I found Veena and Anu better singers than others including him. Faculty knows better. One more thing I would like to mention here, better humans perform better in arts and therefore, I think he needs to improve in this department to succeed in life.

I wish the contestants best of luck in their life. One more point I would like to mention here, I am not a music guru but just an enthusiast and still, I have seen a sea change in the contestants’ proficiency here.
I want to see more of such shows as SKCH and not SKD. It has created a few bad people and a monster in Ali Mughal. One more thing that I am against is that there is no transparency in public voting and that is where the show gets rigged. I think these shows are reaching that stage now.
Edited on 18-06-2009
One close friend of mine read my article and said I should give benefit of doubt to Ali Mughal as there is a lot of pressure in the game and thus I had commented that I will not comment further but yesterday another friend called me up and said that I have written that comment because I want to be a part of one such show. I here that I had planned to take part in Laughter Challenge II as that is the reality show that a joker like me could be a part of but then I realised I had too many responsibilies taken voluntarily. I could not leave them unattended for a long period. So, the thought is clear and I want to clarify that currently I have no such inclination, that was an emotional outburst. I may not write about any other show but reality shows I will continue to loathe. My love for Sitaron Ko Choona Hai besides comedy shows would remain though.
Now, that I am editing, I can't but share my views further on the shows discussed. SKCH saw the exit of Anu Arora today and SKD Jagdish Italia. Anu Arora's exit was more intense than Veena's and even Padmanav's was more than Veena (who was my favourite because of her non-serious attitude). I used to find Anu melodious than any other contestant and therefore didn't want her exit or for that matter any of the four that sang today. On the other hand, Jagdish's exit was never a problem as he got what he had sown. Yes, he went out at the same time that he bragged to but that exit would have been a king's exit and now he went out like a normal peasant who passed every week on loans and that too from the person he planned his group against. From a person, who stole his wealth in the game and I least want to see as a winner. In SKCH, I think I would back Shantanu Sudame for his honesty and grit. Maybe Neelakshi Bhattacharya (she is my dark horse) for her screen presence and her soft skills. After all the winner will get to cut a music album. While in SKD now, at this point, I will still back Puneesh Sharma for his grit and also because no one else left in the game deserves it more than him as Rashid will not be able to control the amount at stake and Ali - I am sure he will rather misuse it. My dark horse is Sanjiv Gupta (Sanju) who has come back with much planning and yes, he can control the wealth too.
Edited on 27-06-2009
As I am writing this, Yashraj Kapil has already won the show (Sitaron Ko Choona Hai), though Shantanu Sudame became my favourite lately with his show of strength and character and the four contestants in Sarkaar ki Duniya are awaiting the result of their show. The contestants that are in the fray for public voting are: Sanjiv Gupta (my dark horse), Puneesh Sharma (my winner), Rashid Ali (my long time favourite) who lost my favour because of the show of temper one day in the kitchen of the show and of course, Ali Wasim Moghul who, in my view, will use the money for show of power and destruction of the society and therefore, doesn't deserve.
From this platform, I will only request people to vote for their candidate who they think will benefit the society too with the money they receive.