Friday, December 13, 2013

Section 377 - against the order of nature. Is It?

I intended to write on the assembly elections and had not imagined that I would be writing on this subject first, but that blog requires a lot more time, energy and research. I guess, that's why this one came online first.

Section 377 (Indian Penal Code/ Criminal Procedure Code) - presented by Britishers in 1861 and subscribes more to the view of the church. Our learned drafting committee headed by Mr. B R Ambedkar probably didn't even notice this and included it in to to. Congress may have made him a superhero for politics, but I am not very appreciative of the head of a committee which approves looking at the precedent of that very country which looted our country. People may revere their largest and most voluminous book on the constitution, but they missed the slightest point of nationalism while drafting it. I doubt whether they loved their nation like those who gave their lives for the independence of the nation.

That apart, since the SC order, there is outrage in the country supported, of course, by the media. I would not go into the details of why they are going all out to support it. Instead, I would channelise my energy on the issue itself.

What is being termed as a regressive step so vehemently, I would say that is going a bit too far. What they have given is just the interpretation of the draconian law created by some tall leaders of Nehru era. Supreme court can not be asked to make the laws. For that we have parliament and they have rightly diverted the issue to them; who are hiding behind each other instead of giving their position on the issue. If Supreme court starts intervening on every issue and create the laws too, why do we need the parliamentarians? For scams?

Going forward, let us move towards the condition of those who are at the receiving end of this law which was introduced by the British terming it "against the order of nature". The wording itself gives away the source where the term and pressure actually came from. My contention is, if it is actually against the order of nature, then why are there so many people clamouring for it. While the United Kingdom has taken a U-turn on its position since; Indian community of LGBT is (reportedly) still facing the hardships. They have to deal with moral police, extortionists in the police, religious people and the society at large which has been conditioned to like heterosexuality by religious elites and tradition too. I don't know how much pressure is on the community, but there have been numerous reports about closet practitioners of the act as they fear ostracisation and rejection from the society. This is what actually prompted me to write the article.

What suppression and rejection leads to is that people start hiding behind curtains like currently our leadership is doing on the subject. Knowing the risk in keeping the issue and members of the community under the carpet, I'd rather urge the lawmakers and law keepers to encourage them to come out in the open. This will save many lives and give the government correct data of the no of people practicing homosexuality. Remember - "Truth may be like a bitter pill, but a pill is the only cure to a disease".

There should be no discrimination on any count against any person's way of life. If the person is law abiding, peaceful and can contribute to the growth of nation and humanity then why discriminate. If God did not discriminate between different types of people, Who are we to discriminate? Why should we be biased for or against any person just because that person is from some faith, class, profession or has some sexual orientation? In fact, if the religions don't permit them to marry, then they should be allowed to get married in the courts.

Having said that, they should be allowed only if they stay loyal to a single person for a long time and should be allowed to change partner only if they take a proper divorce and they should also be allowed to inherit the partner's wealth and adopt even. This would help the society. We should iron out the kinks in the society and not create them. Laws are to help the society live happily and peacefully and not to make culprits out of ordinary people.

Lastly, I would also like to lobby for giving the full gender status to eunuchs so that there is no stigma of life as a eunuch. They should also be allowed to grow up and live like other children and live a normal citizen's life. In my life, I have never seen any parent giving birth to a eunuch child, still, their nos. are not coming down. I have my suspicion, things would come under control when government actually takes the matter in hand and investigate how their no is growing and how do they bring fresh persons to their fold.

Edited on 25-09-2018

Here is the beautifully written counter view of a friend on the topic providing insight into the world of gays:
http://vikram-sharma.blogspot.com/2010/01/homosexuality-and-society.html

5 comments:

  1. Agree with most of your arguments; just a few things I'm obliged to point out:

    1. It's "Section 377", and not "Article", because it's a part of the Indian Penal Code, and not the Constitution.

    2. Dr Ambedkar was a member of the constituent assembly and was charged to drafting the constitution; I am not aware of the fact that he - or other members of the Constituent Assembly - had the prerogative to overlook amending the criminal procedure code.

    3. Ambedkar resigned from the Assembly over disagreements that people like Nehru and Dr Rajendra Prasad had over the Hindu Code Bill. The HCB sought to emancipate women from oppressive, Brahmanical patriarchal structures; it was revolutionary insofar as it explicitly gave women the rights over property, inheritance, divorce, and adoption, to name a few.

    Thus, for someone who worked tirelessly for the emancipation of Depressed Classes, and women, and even resigned from the Assembly over disagreements that he couldn't compromise over, Ambedkar is, perhaps, one of the greatest statesmen in the history of Indian politics.

    Should he have been alive today, I - and I'm certain host of other scholars would agree with me - am of the idea that he would, wholeheartedly, support amending Section 377.

    Might I also add that the contemporary movement is actually seeking Constitutional redressal, as Section 377 violates the Fundamental Rights, esp. those enshrined under Articles 14, 15 and 21. This castigation of Ambedkar, thus, is unwarranted, and completely unnecessary, and distorts his vision, and his efforts, in defining what truly radial politics was about.

    Cheers!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi.
    Came across your blog on the Nature Daily, and since I’ve written on this topic, too, I thought I’d share my comments. I agree with your post fully, and think it is pertinent to decriminalize a part of sexual expression that can lead to individuals being persecuted.

    Just a few comments otherwise:
    First: It is Section 377, and not “Article” since it is a part of the Indian Penal Code, and not the Constitution.

    Second: B.R. Ambedkar was in-charge of drafting the Constitution, and not – so far as I am aware of it – amending the Indian Penal Code. Doing so, I believe, would be the prerogative of the Parliament (which came into existence only after 1951-52)

    Third: Ambedkar actually resigned from his designation as Law Minister from the Constituent Assembly over disagreements with the Hindu Code Bill – which was, in part, opposed by people like Nehru and Dr Rajendra Prasad. The HCB actually was a remarkable piece of legislation for the time, and fully concomitant in line with Ambedkar vision of emancipation. It gave rights to women in Hindu society to rise up from the oppressive Brahmanical patriarchal systems – it gave a woman the right to equal property and inheritance, divorce rights, adoption and so on.

    So I find it bewildering that, as someone who championed the rights of Depressed Classes and women, Ambedkar can be accused of overseeing Section 377 (which, I’m certain, wasn’t under his purview as such – but I’m open to contradiction).

    If Ambedkar was alive today, I – and I’m certain a host of others would agree with me – he would have surely spoken out against the oppressive Section 377. Mainly so, because it violates the Fundamental Rights enshrined in the Constitution of India – a document that Ambedkar drafted – under articles 14, 15 and 21. In fact, the Delhi High Court upheld these very same principles.

    That’s all. Good luck! Cheers!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your detailed reply Proshant. Thanks for providing me some more issues for research. Whatever I have written is on the basis of whatever I have read about Dr Ambedkar. I will read about these attributes of Dr Ambedkar too and modify the blog, if necessary.

      Regards,

      Sanjay

      Delete
  3. I apologise for the silliness; I unknowingly posted two same comments.

    Sure, I'm glad I could make the points.

    One book you could read is 'Against the Madness of Manu', which is edited and introduced by Sharmila Rege (Navyana, 2013).

    Cheers!

    ReplyDelete
  4. No problem with that Proshant. This is just a minor mistake. Anyway, shall read the book but this may take time.

    ReplyDelete